Submit Story

Homepage
All CNHINS News
    Crime
    Disasters
    Education
    Environment
    General news
    Latino
    Military
    Government
    Politics
    Weather
Lifestyle
    Arts
    Automotive
    Books
    Entertainment
    Faith
    Family
    Fashion
    Fitness
    Food
    Garden
    Health
    Homes
    How-to
    Local history
    Medicine
    Science
    Seniors
    Technology
    Travel
Opinion
    Columns
    Editorials
Sports
    Sports, college
    Sports, high school
    Sports, local
    Sports Opinion
    Outdoors
    Sports, pro
Business
    Agriculture
    Energy / Oil and Gas
    Finance
    Real estate
CNHIns Originals
Talkers

News & reporting
Page design
Photography
On the Web
Ethics and Standards
Management and culture

Tom Lindley
national editor
812-282-1012 tlindley@cnhi.com

J.B. Blosser Bittner
deputy national editor
405-255-2985
jbittner@cnhi.com

Bill Ketter
CNHI vice president for editorial
978-946-2233
wketter@cnhi.com

May 01, 2008 09:42 am

Editorial: Who’s too old now, Jack?

John Murtha wasn’t the first person to weigh in on the John McCain age issue. He won’t be the last. But we wonder whether one day he’ll wish he hadn’t.


CNHI News Service

Editorial: Who’s too old now, Jack?

Opinion: The Tribune-Democrat, Johnstown, Pa.


Visitors to The Tribune-Democrat’s Web site were asked in a poll last week: “Is John McCain, 71, too old to serve as president of the United States, as Congressman John Murtha says?” With 556 votes cast during two days, the results were: No, 64.6 percent; Yes, 34.7 percent; and I don’t know: 0.7 percent.
Murtha wasn’t the first person to weigh in on the John McCain age issue. He won’t be the last. But we wonder whether one day he’ll wish he hadn’t.
“This one guy running is about as old as me,” Murtha said, drawing laughter and applause from a Washington conference about to hear his own endorsed candidate, Hillary Clinton.
The 75-year-old Murtha, of course, was referring to the fact that McCain is only four years younger and, if elected, would be the oldest man to become president at age 72.
The rigors and stress of running the country, Murtha contended, are too much for guys their age.
Perhaps Murtha’s lightheartedness was just a case of getting caught up in the moment.
As for McCain, his response to Murtha was: “All I can tell you is that I admire and respect Jack Murtha. Speak for yourself, Jack. I’m doing fine. Thanks.”
Perhaps, though, Murtha could soon find himself the butt of age jokes as he continues to seek re-election.
There has even been speculation that should Clinton go on to win the presidency, it could position Murtha for an administration post, even defense secretary.
That is, of course, unless Murtha has already declared himself too old.

Story Title

Story Body

Pick your state

© 2008 Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI News Service
3500 Colonnade Parkway, Suite 600, Birmingham, AL 35243; (205) 298-7100